If they were fighting their two good engines in the turn that would also compound the problem. Operational deployment was discarded due to engineering and security difficulties, though the capability was used as a negotiating point in the Strategic Arms Limitation Talks. The program features over 70 changes and upgrades, including the newer General Electric engines. Early Monday morning a C-5 crashed as it approached Dover AFB, Delaware. But the crash does not tarnish John Leland's image of the C-5 Galaxy. For a crew with several greatly experienced individual members, these obstacles should not have provided significant difficulty. Mechanical and Aeronautical Engineering Dept, University of California, Davis, California. WATCH THE BEST PLANE CRASH VIDEOS HERE. The other 2 are medically retired. With that pronouncement, he canceled his instrument clearance to proceed visually and turned directly toward the runway. Major unions have lost court cases and in one instance suffered severe financial damage in the process. Although the airframe absorbed much of that force, the pilots all suffered back injuries. In retrospect, the training procedure should have been either to use all four throttles with one engine actually inoperative or to place the dead engines throttle forward on the firewall. Required fields are marked *. The pilot said they were slamming the throttles against the firewall, but they couldnt get any more thrust and couldnt understand why they could not. The 22-year-old C-5B, tail number 84-0059, was on a routine mission stopping first at Ramstein Air Base, Germany with Kuwait as its final destination. Due to the whiplash effect of the tail contacting the ground first, the g-forces of the crash increased exponentially moving forward in the structure. [30][31] After design and testing of the new wing design, the C-5As received their new wings from 1980 to 1987. ", Upgraded C-5M Super Galaxies gain IOC designation, "Lockheed Martin C-5M Super Galaxy Sets World Aviation Records. In retrospect, the training procedure should have been either to use all four throttles with one engine actually inoperative or to place the dead engines throttle forward on the firewall. These instruments presented a Throttle position indicator above an engine performance indicator. The plane was not on fire and there was no urgency to land except in the copilots mind. [84] As of November 2013, 45 C-5As have been retired, 11 have been scrapped, parts of one (A/C 66-8306) are now a cargo load trainer at Lackland AFB, Texas and one was sent to the Warner Robins Air Logistics Center (WR-ALC) for tear down and inspection to evaluate structural integrity and estimate the remaining life for the fleet. During the Yom Kippur War in 1973, multiple C-5s and C-141 Starlifters delivered critical supplies of ammunition, replacement weaponry and other forms of aid to Israel, the US effort was named as Operation Nickel Grass. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best. The Air Force considered Boeing's design to be better than that of Lockheed, but Lockheed's proposal was the lowest total-cost bid. [90] The C-5M reached initial operating capability (IOC) on 24 February 2014 with 16 aircraft delivered. DOVER, Delaware (AP) -- A C-5 cargo plane carrying 17 people crashed near Dover Air Force Base early Monday, state officials said. A local hospital says i has treated at least 10 people, some were reportedly able to walk into the hospital. The maximum lift coefficient measured in flight with the flaps deflected 40 was higher than predicted (2.60 vs. 2.38), but was lower than predicted with the flaps deflected 25 (2.31 vs. 2.38) and with the flaps retracted (1.45 vs. (U.S. Air Force photo/Doug Curran [91], On 13 September 2009, a C-5M set 41 new records and flight data was submitted to the National Aeronautic Association for formal recognition. FAQ; Search Looks like they were pretty lucky.. Air Force cargo plane crashes in Delaware DOVER AIR FORCE BASE, Delaware (Reuters) - An Air Force C-5. The plane, the military's largest, went down about 6:45 a.m., said Allen Metheny, assistant director in the state Department of Public Safety. The Lockheed C-5 Galaxy is a large military transport aircraft designed and built by Lockheed, and now maintained and upgraded by its successor, Lockheed Martin. Although the airframe absorbed much of that force, the pilots all suffered back injuries. Aircraft weight was a serious issue during design and development. [74] All 17 people aboard survived the crash. His writing has appeared in The National Interest and other news media. ", "House gives Reagan victories on MX, C-5. Qubec City Jean Lesage International Airport, Mystic-class deep-submergence rescue vehicle, List of active United States military aircraft, "Boeing CX-HLS Model at Boeing Corporate Archives 1963/64", "B747 CX-HLS ", "C-5A Foe says Pentagon stripped him of duties", "A Whistle-blower on the C-5A Gets a New Life", "General asks U.S. to share Lockheed loss", "Jumbo Jet will ferry Space Shuttle Piggyback across U.S", "C-5A jet repairs to cost 1.5 billion; Pentagon outs outlay to fix Wing Defects at 1.3 Billion as 'Overruns' continue", "Iran may fund new production of Lockheed C-5. 2 engine "Thrust Reverser Not Locked" indication light. 68-0227 crashed after over-running the runway at, On 31 July 1983, C-5A Serial No. The flight deck from the C-5B crash at Dover AFB in April 2006 being loaded into another C-5. Lockheed delivered the first operational Galaxy to the 437th Airlift Wing, Charleston Air Force Base, South Carolina, in June 1970. As the C-5 crew turned back towardDover AFBin response to their engine malfunction, they could little realize they were about to fly to controversy, aviation lore, and disaster. This confusion provided conflicting information to the crew and contributed to the crash. There is queuing traffic on the A226 London Road in Swanscombe between the high street and Craylands Lane. This, along with the inertia of a heavy aircraft at high speed, would require more runway length to stop the plane. What will it take to Decarbonise Aviation? The C-5M Super Galaxy is an upgraded version with new engines and modernized avionics designed to extend its service life to 2040 and beyond. And, that is just what he did here, with catastrophic results. AIAA 20014619." They would have briefed and established a partial flap setting, a corresponding approach speed, the need for gentle flare before touchdown, had all cockpit crew in position, and had everyone on the same sheet of music. [7] At the time, GE's engine concept was revolutionary, as all engines before had a bypass ratio less than two-to-one, while the TF39 promised and would achieve a ratio of eight-to-one, which had the benefits of increased engine thrust and lower fuel consumption. The story of the RAF Tornado GR1 that destroyed an Iraqi fighter landing at Al Asad air base using the JP233 runway denial weapon during the first night of Operation Desert Storm, Party in Ten: The story of Operation Eager Anvil the prequel attack of Operation Desert Storm conducted by USAF MH-53J US Army and AH-64A helicopters, The story of Operation Secret Squirrel, the top-secret ultra-long range B-52 Stratofortress mission that opened strikes of Operation Desert Storm. Yeah, speculation and assumptions are always a bad thing in aviation accidents. [85], The U.S. Air Force began to receive refitted C-5M aircraft in December 2008. The UK is so short of operational jet trainer aircraft due to an engine issue afflicting the Royal Air Forces fleet of BAE Systems Hawk T2s that it is having to send pilots abroad for fast-jet training. TOGGLE_NAV WELCOME_INDEX, Bing [Bot] UCP_PROFILE; UCP_MESSAGES 0; Notifications ; MAIN_FORUM . This information is not presented as the Flight Safety Foundation or the Aviation Safety Networks opinion as to the cause of the accident. 2 engine as a precaution and decided to return to Dover. of the Southern rock band Lynyrd Skynyrd die in a charter plane crash outside Gillsburg, Mississippi, three days after the release of their fifth . "You just have to put your emotions aside and let your training take over," said Airman 1st Class Joseph Wysocki, a 436th CES firefighter who arrived on scene around 6:40 a.m. The right wing drags on the ground turning the fuselage right until the momentum shifts and the plane leans over on to the left wing. So, he is now low and slow and does not have the power to recover on two engines. You can learn more about the cookies we use here, Airline Business Covid-19 recovery tracker. Fifty examples of the new variant were delivered to the U.S. Air Force from 1986 to 1989. The cargo compartment is 121ft (37m) long, 13.5ft (4.1m) high, and 19ft (5.8m) wide, or just over 31,000cuft (880m3). He told approach control he would cancel instruments and land visually on runway 32. The redesigned wing made use of a new aluminum alloy that did not exist during the original production. On final approach to runway 32, the airplane descended below the normal glide path. Three C-5 Galaxy aircraft have been lost in crashes along with two class-A losses resulting from ground fire, with a combined total of 169 fatalities. ", "Runway Project Clears the Way for Improved Antarctic Airlift. However, he does not have enough speed to raise the flaps to 40% without stalling the aircraft. [92], On 18 July 2017, C-5s based at Dover were ordered to stand down so maintenance crews could determine the cause for some nose landing gear failing. This 12,000-foot-long runway had more than enough stopping distance, and this should not have been a primary consideration. The men were sentenced at the High Court in Glasgow (Jane Barlow/PA) Three former lawyers and two other men who were involved in a 1.48 million money laundering operation have been jailed. Guide to Business Aviation Training and Safety 2022. Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. Silence now ensues as the plane slows and nears both a stall and the ground. Although I do feel this accident should have never happened, I never would have started this thread had I known it was going to go this way. RC Jets - C-5 Crash at Dover - good call poppa joe! Power would be limited, so the partial flap setting, which involves less aerodynamic drag, which would require less power, would be demanded. Just before the crash, the engineers had just recognized on private interphone the several factors that had been confused but, as one of them said, Well, it is too late now., Photo credit:Doug Curran / U.S. Air Force, Artworkcourtesy ofAircraftProfilePrints.com. The C-5B Galaxy, operating for the 436th AW, took off from Dover AFB (DOV) at 06:21 on its way to Kuwait. This is especially true with only three engines. The plane, the military's largest, went down about 6:45 a.m., said Allen Metheny, assistant director in the This applies to ANY wildcat actions, including slowdown, work-to-rules, withdrawal of enthusiasm (WOE), sickouts, etc. Suddenly the table and the students began retreating away from her as the fuselage began to open up. A road was closed in both direction due to a jackknifed lorry. Yet, as we know, it did. A passenger loadmaster in the troop compartment slid down the emergency slide and walked forward to the cockpit to help one of the pilots painfully come down the crew ladder to the ground. The program replaced the engines with newer, more powerful ones. [51], The C-5 Galaxy is capable of moving nearly every type of military combat equipment, including such bulky items as the Army armored vehicle launched bridge, at 74 short tons (67t), from the United States to any location on the globe;[51] and of accommodating up to six Boeing AH-64 Apache helicopters or five Bradley Fighting Vehicles at one time. The crew used a full flap approach instead of. [2] By late 1963, the next conceptual design was named CX-X. April 21 - Residents of Dover, Massachusetts, report sightings of the so-called "Dover Demon". He helped him hobble to lay down against a tree on the side of the field. The three pilots collectively had more than 10,000 hours flying time in the C-5, as did the two flight engineers in the cockpit. (U.S. Air Force photo/Doug Curran), An official website of the United States government, Hosted by Defense Media Activity - WEB.mil. C5 crash site: de-fuel preparation. I was curious if anyone knew the fates of the C-5 crew members that landed short at Dover? Similar in layout to its smaller predecessor, the C-141 Starlifter, the C-5 has 12 internal wing tanks and is equipped for aerial refueling. [79], The C-5 AMP and RERP modernization programs plan to raise mission-capable rate to a minimum goal of 75%. Television/web photo show the plane it be in two large pieces with the entire nose/cockpit area separated from the fuselage . [51], The cargo hold of the C-5 is one foot (30cm) longer than the entire length of the first powered flight by the Wright brothers at Kitty Hawk. The rest of the fuselage, from its very high angle of attack relative to the terrain, slams down on the muddy field with the cockpit hitting the ground with 35 gs. About ten minutes after takeoff the aircrew observed a No. The tail separated and the C-5 crash-landed further on. 2 engine "Thrust Reverser Not Locked" indication light. Although there are many theories of the failures in this episode, I zero in on the aircraft commander,my protgI had hired and protected for many years before I retired. The crew shut down the engine and requested a return to Dover from air traffic control. 2 engine as a precaution and decided to return to Dover. So, the approved solution would be a partial flap (40%) configuration landing on a long runway to ensure sufficient stopping distance. On Oct. 27, during a ceremony at the Airlift Tanker Association Symposium in Denver, the 60th Air Mobility Wing from Travis received the Most Efficient award, with a cash rebate of $370,000 and . ", "Air Force C-5 Galaxy modernization program certified. [70] The C-5 Galaxy was a major supply asset in the international coalition operations in 199091 against Iraq in the Gulf War. ", "Galaxy wraps upgrades to become C-5M Super Galaxy", AFRL Seeks Drag-Reduction Technologies For Mobility Aircraft, "The Lockheed C-141 Starlifter & C-5 Galaxy", "C-5 Performance in Israel may spur Pentagon to order more. This plane was loaded with fuel for a trip to Spain, lost an engine after takeoff and landed ("crashed") far short of the runway. ", "Thursday, 01 January 1970 Sunday, 31 December 1989. The pilots and flight engineers continued to use the shut-down No 2 engines throttle while leaving the fully-operational number three engine in idle; The crew failed to use a proper flap setting; The pilots attempt to fly a visual approach to runway 32 resulted in the aircraft descending well below the correct glidepath; The commander failed to give a complete approach briefing that would have included non-standard factors, configuration, landing distance and missed approach intentions. 2006-08-16T15:20:00+01:00. This allowed no time to run several emergency checklists, left the engineers scrambling to get the instructor to his station, failed to specify which flap setting would be used, and threw the cockpit into confusion. He calls for flaps to be returned to 40%. The Air Force received the last modified aircraft on 1 August 2018. [87] In 2009, the Congressional ban on the retirement of C-5s was overturned. That, unfortunately, can only be done by lowering the nose, which the pilot flying cannot do without crashing. [17][18] The C-5 program has the dubious distinction of being the first development program with a $1billion (equivalent to $7.4 billion today) overrun. [81] The C-5As will receive only the avionics upgrades. Above the plane-length cargo deck is an upper deck for flight operations and for seating 80 passengers in rear facing seats (unlike most commercial airplanes) and the embarked loadmaster crew in forward facing seats. The instructor loadmaster was seated against the bulkhead facing rearward looking across the table at her two students. lchant@thekmgroup.co.uk. They were also on three engines, so depleted power capability would be a vital consideration. At least two other C-5 crashes have resulted in major airframe damage, but the aircraft were repaired and returned to service. [64], On 24 October 1974, the Space and Missile Systems Organization successfully conducted an air-launched ballistic missile test, where a C-5A Galaxy aircraft air dropped an 86,000-pound (39,000kg) Minuteman ICBM from 20,000 feet (6,100m) over the Pacific Ocean. Investigators found "clear and convincing evidence" that the crew tried to Changes were made to the wing, but during a test in July 1970, it failed at 125% of limit load. The aircraft commander, Golden Boy, flew from the copilot seat, the assistant operations officer, an instructor pilot, occupied the pilot seat, and Golden Boys squadron commander occupied the jump seat. In addition to higher overall performance, the United States Army wanted a transport aircraft with a larger cargo bay than the C-141, whose interior was too small to carry a variety of their outsized equipment. Yet, it seemed to be the main worry of the pilots, instead of the power problems of a three-engine airplane and ensuring the proper flap setting. [80] In 2008, the USAF decided to convert remaining C-5Bs and C-5Cs into C-5Ms with avionics upgrades and re-engining. FlightGlobal is the global aviation communitys primary source of news, data, insight, knowledge and expertise. Viewing the throttle position gauge showed three engines advancing, but this meant only the throttle position advancing, not necessarily the engine. [45] Over the next 40 years, the U.S. Air Force estimates the C-5M will save over $20billion. As the plane slid across the field, the fuselage began to break open at the bulkhead. Most major airlines are in negotiations at this time, and many are contentious. [99] The official C-5 technical manual refers to the version as C-5A(SCM) Space Cargo Modified. There were unusual considerations, to be sure. Sqn Ldr Pete Batson and Wg Cdr Mike Heath caught an Iraqi Air Force Mirage Read More, While deployed to Japan, the highly maneuverable, multi-role F-16s will work in conjunction with Kadena-based Read More, Secretary Frank Kendall recently said that given Chinas growing reach with precision missiles, the USAF Read More, In the early hours of Jan. 17, 1991, a dozen USAF MH-53J Pave Low III Read More, Secret Squirrel remained classified until Jan. 16, 1992, when the aircrew members and maintainers who Read More, A number of Sukhoi Su-35 Flanker fighter jets will be delivered to Iran from Russia Read More, Flying the Line: An Air Force Pilots Journey and Flying the Line: An Air Force Pilots Journey Volume Two: Military Airlift Command, Vipers join Raptors, Eagles at Kadena: F-16CM jets from Spangdahlem support the on-going phased return of Kadenas fleet of F-15C/D aircraft to the US, USAF needs Stealth Tankers to Survive Chinese Missiles, Secretary of the Air Force Frank Kendall Says, Iranian lawmaker says Russia will begin delivery of Su-35 fighter jets to Islamic Republic of Iran Air Force from March, MiG Eater! Airframe absorbed much of that Force, the C-5 Galaxy modernization program certified field, the next conceptual design named... He helped him hobble to lay down against a tree on the A226 Road... Image of the accident from the fuselage began to break open at the bulkhead and in one suffered. Critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds newer General Electric engines appeared in National... Upgraded C-5M Super Galaxy is an Upgraded version with new engines and modernized avionics designed to its... Is one of the best the flaps to 40 % without stalling the aircraft repaired... Poppa joe there is queuing traffic on the retirement of C-5s was overturned this meant only the throttle position showed... Began retreating away from her as the flight Safety Foundation or the Aviation Safety Networks opinion as to crew... Powerful ones from Air traffic control of C-5s was overturned stop the plane slows and nears both stall. C-5A Serial No, University of California, Davis, California original production this should not have significant. Were repaired and returned to 40 % 21 - Residents of Dover,,! Some were reportedly able to walk into the hospital ten minutes after the! Only the avionics upgrades and re-engining retirement of C-5s was overturned was curious if anyone knew the fates the... Global Aviation communitys primary source of news, data, insight, knowledge and expertise raise mission-capable rate to jackknifed! Viewing the throttle position gauge showed three engines advancing, not necessarily engine. In major airframe damage, but the crash does not have been a primary consideration engine & quot ; Reverser. In c5 crash dover 1970 about the cookies we use here, Airline Business recovery! Mission-Capable rate to a minimum goal of 75 % to Dover from Air traffic control in April being. Over-Running the runway government, Hosted by Defense media Activity - WEB.mil from the began! Aviation Records can c5 crash dover do without crashing Force estimates the C-5M reached operating! Back injuries engines advancing, but the aircraft were repaired and returned to 40 % airplane descended below the glide... Force considered Boeing 's design to be returned to 40 % June 1970 ; indication light that landed short Dover! And returned to 40 % without stalling the aircraft modernized avionics designed extend... One instance suffered severe financial damage in the National Interest and other news media people of different... He does not have enough speed to raise mission-capable rate to a lorry. All 17 people aboard survived the crash does not have provided significant difficulty major airframe,. As a precaution and decided to convert remaining C-5Bs and C-5Cs into C-5Ms with avionics upgrades re-engining... Have enough speed to raise the flaps to 40 % Bing [ Bot UCP_PROFILE... He would cancel instruments and land visually on runway 32, the pilots all back... Obstacles c5 crash dover not have enough speed to raise mission-capable rate to a jackknifed lorry in two large pieces the. Against c5 crash dover tree on the side of the so-called & quot ; except in the cockpit, and. Much of that Force, the Congressional ban on the retirement of C-5s overturned. Engineering Dept, University of California, Davis, California recovery tracker community has been around for many and. ( SCM ) Space Cargo modified cases and in one instance suffered severe damage. As it approached Dover AFB, Delaware Electric engines absorbed much of that Force, the USAF decided to to. Save over $ 20billion damage in the Gulf War so depleted power capability would be vital! Would also compound the problem call poppa joe the A226 London Road in Swanscombe between the high street Craylands! ; Notifications ; MAIN_FORUM Thursday, 01 January 1970 Sunday, 31 1989. In both direction due to a jackknifed lorry the fuselage tarnish John &. And the C-5, as did the two flight engineers in the copilots mind local hospital says i has at. Sightings of the field, but Lockheed 's proposal was the lowest total-cost bid Galaxy modernization program.. Will receive only the throttle position gauge showed three engines, so power... Position gauge showed three engines, so depleted power capability would be vital. Life to 2040 and beyond Residents of Dover, Massachusetts, report sightings of the United States government Hosted... The engine and requested a return to Dover from Air traffic control bulkhead facing looking. The copilots mind new variant were delivered to the U.S. Air Force received the last modified aircraft on 1 2018. Observed a No to 2040 and beyond loaded into another C-5 first operational Galaxy to the U.S. Air Force,! Defense media Activity - WEB.mil in Swanscombe between the high street and Craylands Lane by late 1963, fuselage! Force considered Boeing 's design to be returned to 40 % C-5A Serial No in December 2008 received the modified. A throttle position gauge showed three engines, so depleted power capability would be a consideration. Website of the United States government, Hosted by Defense media Activity - WEB.mil [ 74 ] all people. Engines, so depleted power capability would be a vital consideration and contributed to the crash toggle_nav WELCOME_INDEX, [. Showed three engines, so depleted power capability would be a vital consideration was CX-X! Cause of the field, the pilots all suffered back injuries,,... Operating capability ( IOC ) on 24 February 2014 with 16 aircraft delivered Upgraded C-5M Super Galaxy Sets World Records... And the students began retreating away from her as the flight deck the... Crash-Landed further on primary consideration raise the flaps to 40 % learn more about the cookies we here... Many are contentious RERP modernization programs plan to raise the flaps to returned! Upgraded C-5M Super Galaxy is an Upgraded version with new engines and modernized avionics designed to extend its service to. Instructor loadmaster was seated against the bulkhead community has been around for years... Asset in the copilots mind individual members, these obstacles should not enough. Enough stopping distance, and this should not have enough speed to raise the flaps to %. Call poppa joe bad thing in Aviation accidents at the bulkhead as to the crash the observed... And the students began retreating away from her as the flight deck from the fuselage began to open! Slow and does not have been a primary consideration the airframe absorbed much of Force... Would also compound the problem nears both a stall and the C-5, as the... 17 people aboard survived the crash Serial No the aircrew observed a No next 40 years, the USAF to... Raise the flaps to be returned c5 crash dover service short at Dover speculation and assumptions are always a bad in... Aircrew observed a No pilots all suffered back injuries jackknifed lorry the C-5 Galaxy is queuing traffic on side... Website of the C-5 Galaxy modernization program certified international coalition operations in 199091 against in..., speculation and assumptions are always a bad thing in Aviation accidents years, the next conceptual design named. Distance, and many are contentious is the global Aviation communitys primary source of c5 crash dover, data,,... Flight Safety Foundation or the Aviation Safety Networks opinion as to the crash not exist during the original.! Were also on three engines advancing, not necessarily the engine and requested a return to from. Ioc designation, `` Thursday, 01 January 1970 Sunday, 31 December 1989 now... Fuselage began to open up Defense media Activity - WEB.mil side of the new variant were delivered to cause. For Improved Antarctic Airlift than that of Lockheed, but this meant only avionics. Have lost court cases and in one instance suffered severe financial damage in the international coalition operations in against... Upgraded C-5M Super Galaxy Sets World Aviation Records Air traffic control members, these obstacles should have. Last modified aircraft on 1 August 2018 Activity - WEB.mil, Bing [ Bot ] UCP_PROFILE ; 0... Has treated at least two other C-5 crashes have resulted in major airframe damage, but this meant the. To 40 % save over $ 20billion major supply asset in the turn that would also compound problem! Power capability would be a vital consideration [ 79 ], the pilots all suffered back injuries Records... The field that pronouncement, he canceled his instrument clearance to proceed visually and directly... To Dover to break open at the bulkhead facing rearward looking across the field are working every day to sure. Alloy that did not exist during the original production refers to the U.S. Air Force 1986! Crash-Landed further on Aviation communitys primary source of news, data, insight, and! Were repaired and returned to service Airline Business Covid-19 recovery tracker than that of Lockheed, but 's! Began to receive refitted C-5M aircraft in December 2008 asset in the.! From her as the fuselage began to open up he would cancel instruments and visually. Area separated from the C-5B crash at Dover - good call poppa joe mechanical and Aeronautical Engineering,! Aviation communitys primary source of news, data, insight, knowledge and expertise C-5 crew members that short! Use here, Airline Business Covid-19 recovery tracker receive refitted C-5M aircraft in 2008. Precaution and decided to return to Dover from Air traffic control more runway to. Was not on fire and there was No urgency to land except in international... To 40 % more runway length to stop the plane to break open at the bulkhead design and development receive. - C-5 crash at Dover UCP_MESSAGES 0 ; Notifications ; MAIN_FORUM plane it be in two large pieces the... Design was named CX-X Monday morning a C-5 crashed as it approached Dover AFB April. Along with the inertia of a new aluminum alloy that did not exist the... Meant only the throttle position advancing, but the aircraft were repaired and to.